An Old News Story Ranks for Your Name: What You Can Do
Google rarely takes a lawful news article out of its results. Its own help pages say it won’t remove information that’s valuable to the public, and they name newspapers as an example. Your realistic options are to ask the publisher to update, correct or de-identify the story, complain to the Australian Press Council if it’s inaccurate, ask Google to refresh its results once the page has changed, and push the story further down with suppression. If the article is false and seriously harmful, get legal advice.
This article walks through each option in the order that usually makes sense, what to expect from each, and what to avoid.
The short version
- Google usually leaves news results up, because it treats news as valuable to the public.
- The publisher controls the article. A calm, specific request for an update, correction or de-identification is the best first step.
- Inaccurate stories can go to the Australian Press Council, if the publisher is a member. Complaints should normally be made within 30 days of first publication, though late complaints can be considered with good reason.
- When the page changes, Google catches up. You can speed that up with Google’s refresh tool.
- If the story stays, suppression can push it down. It doesn’t delete the article, and Google decides the order of results.
Why Google usually leaves news results up
Google’s tool for removing personal information says it “won’t remove info that’s valuable to the public”, and lists educational or government institutions and newspapers. Its private information page says the same about news: “if the content is about something important or newsworthy, like the news, Google might not take it down.”
So a request to Google to remove a news story just because it’s old or embarrassing is unlikely to succeed. Google’s removal processes are built for specific things, such as exposed contact details, sensitive personal information, intimate images and doxxing. Our guide Removal vs suppression lists what Google will and won’t remove.
Step 1: Check what is actually ranking
Before you contact anyone, get a clear picture:
- Search your name the way others would, in a private browser window, and note every result about the story.
- Work out which pages are the original. A story often appears on the publisher’s site and on syndicated copies, aggregators or forum posts that quote it.
- Note what’s wrong with it, if anything. Is it inaccurate, out of date (for example, it doesn’t mention how a case ended), or accurate but painful?
This tells you who to contact and what to ask for.
Step 2: Ask the publisher
The publisher decides what happens to its article, so start there. Find the editor or the corrections or contact address on the publication’s website, and keep your request short, calm and factual.
Things you can reasonably ask for:
- An update. For example, a note that charges were dropped, a case was dismissed, or a business has changed hands.
- A correction, if facts in the story are wrong. Include evidence.
- De-identification. Removing your name or photo from an older story where you were not the main subject.
- Removal. Possible, but the least likely outcome for an accurate story.
It’s the publisher’s decision. If it agrees to change or remove the article, the original search result will change over time too.
Step 3: If the story is inaccurate, the Australian Press Council
The Australian Press Council is the main body that responds to complaints about Australian newspapers, magazines and their websites. Its binding Statement of General Principles asks publications to make sure factual material is “accurate and not misleading”, and to “provide a correction or other adequate remedial action if published material is significantly inaccurate or misleading”. It also covers privacy and avoiding harm, unless publication is “sufficiently in the public interest”.
Before you complain, check:
- Who published it. The Council’s jurisdiction covers publications of its member publishers (“constituent bodies”), which include most Australian newspapers and magazines and some digital-only publishers. It says the only major newspaper not published by a member is The West Australian. It may consider complaints about other publishers, but they aren’t obliged to cooperate.
- What kind of outlet it is. Complaints about ABC or SBS online articles go to those broadcasters, and TV or radio complaints go to the broadcaster or the Australian Communications and Media Authority.
- The time limit. Complaints “normally should be made within thirty days of the first publication”. For an older story you need to ask for approval, for example because you had a reasonable justification for not noticing it earlier, or you spent time unsuccessfully seeking a response from the publication.
You can complain to the publication first, at the same time, or go straight to the Council. Details are on its Information for complainants page.
Step 4: Once the page changes, refresh Google
If the publisher removes the article, Google drops it from its results over time. If the old version still shows up, use Google’s Refresh outdated content tool, which is for content that “was deleted from a site but still comes up in Google Search results”. If the page has been updated and is still live, Google says you don’t need to use the form.
Step 5: If the story stays, suppression
Most accurate news stories stay online. Suppression is the practical option: building up accurate, relevant pages about you, such as a professional profile, your business website, and genuine coverage of your work, so they compete with the story on the searches that matter.
Be realistic about it:
- A major news site can be hard to outrank, so it takes steady, ongoing work.
- The article still exists. Suppression changes where it ranks, not whether it’s there.
- Nobody can guarantee a ranking. Google decides the order of results.
When it’s a legal issue
If a story makes false statements of fact that seriously harm you, it may be a legal matter as well as an editorial one. Speak to a lawyer about your situation before you contact the journalist or post anything publicly. Google takes reports of content that “violates the law or your rights” through its Legal Help Center, but it reviews each request itself.
What not to do
- Don’t threaten or abuse the journalist or editor. It rarely helps, and a heated exchange can become a story of its own.
- Don’t publish fake articles, fake reviews or fake profiles to bury the story. It’s dishonest, and Google’s spam policies target content created to manipulate rankings.
- Don’t pay anyone who guarantees a news article will be “deleted from Google”. Google and the publisher decide.
- Don’t pay a site that charges to remove content about you. Google has a separate policy for sites with exploitative removal practices, and may remove those pages from its results on request.
How RepDefender can help
We look at what ranks for your name today and tell you honestly what’s possible. If there’s a real removal route, such as personal information Google’s policies cover, we’ll say so. If the story is lawful and accurate, our Search Result Suppression service builds and promotes accurate, positive pages so they compete for the top spots, and we report on progress as we go.
We’re not Google, and we don’t publish fake content or attack other people’s pages. Publishers decide what happens to their articles, and Google decides what ranks.
FAQ
Can I get Google to remove an old news article about me?
Usually not. Google says it won’t remove information that’s valuable to the public, and names newspapers as an example. The publisher controls the article, so asking it to update, correct or de-identify the story is a better first step.
Will a publisher take an article down if I ask?
It’s the publisher’s decision. Accurate stories are rarely removed, but a polite, specific request for an update, a correction or removing your name from an older story is often worth making.
How long do I have to complain to the Australian Press Council?
The Council says complaints should normally be made within 30 days of first publication. For older material you can ask it to consider the complaint anyway, for example if you had a good reason for not noticing it earlier.
What if the charges were dropped or I was found not guilty?
Ask the publisher to add an update noting the outcome, with evidence. An accurate update changes what people read when they find the story, even if it still ranks.
Does suppression delete the article?
No. Suppression pushes accurate, stronger pages above the story so fewer people see it. The article stays online.
Is removal guaranteed?
No. The publisher decides what happens to its article, and Google decides what appears in its results. Anyone who guarantees a removal is overclaiming.
Not sure what can be done?
Send us the search terms and the results that worry you. We’ll tell you, free, whether removal looks possible or suppression is the better fit, and if we can’t help, we’ll say so. Get a free assessment.
Sources
- Google Search Help: Find and remove personal info in Google Search results
- Google Search Help: Remove my private info from Google Search
- Google Search Help: Refresh outdated content
- Google Search Help: Remove content about you on exploitative sites that try to charge for removal
- Google Legal Help: Report content for legal reasons
- Google Search Central: Spam policies for Google web search
- Australian Press Council: Complaints
- Australian Press Council: Information for complainants
- Australian Press Council: Make a complaint
- Australian Press Council: Statement of Principles
